Place the potatoes directly on the rack. i may not want one now, but by the time it's done, who knows? Goodness. You’ll be left with soggy potatoes instead of crispy ones. My. If you're … I do this often...I cook pork shoulder roasts about once a week. Karen ~ Thanks for sharing our experience. +. Take the big russet potatoes, rub them in oil, and stand them up on end, in a big crock pot, and turn it on for the entire day while you're gone. Hilarious Exchange Between Rach & John About What They Ate On First Date (LOL & Awww), "Sorry, honey," Rach says after sweetly correcting John & remembering perfectly how the night went. I will always give them a few pokes with a knife after that misfortune. ~ Alanna. I stumbled across this page while looking for potato-cooking times and decided to try the three-hour version. instead of a 1lb. I also wrap my potatoes because I like the skins to be soft. I have had unpricked potatoes explode multiple times. Those who were cooking a big batch might consider to raise the temp by 25° for the first hour. Wrap potatoes in a large piece of aluminum foil, making sure the foil wraps around the potato at least twice. Bake at 400° F for about one hour, or until tender. This is a wonderful story, Alanna, and I will try it. Marni ~ I haven’t tried a sweet potato but somehow think that two or three hours would be a looong time for a sweet potato, maybe because of the less-dense texture? Everyone has their own preference. I made these Sunday nite. Take this money personality quiz from personal finance expert Rachel Cruze to find out. Three hours? After another 30 minutes, put Potato #3 in the oven. The one time I went against "conventional wisdom" and tried to bake potatoes without pricking them, I had a *huge* exploded potato mess in my oven. Thanks! OH, but it was still good...just a little to crunchy. Hi Alanna - yes, I've baked them the full 3 hours after poking them all over with a fork, and they were outstanding! ~M ~ You know, I don't think so, I have the idea that they'd just shrivel up. Bad idea! I wasn't even sure you would respond at all, and certainly not so quickly. And I thought that 1-hour baked potato was top notch!? If you can find smaller potatoes (good for portion management), I would check them after two hours, then decide how to proceed. Hubby thought they were the best baked potato he'd ever eaten. Yeek! Sweet potatoes are also packed with vitamin A, vitamin C and fiber, making them a nutritious vegetable choice. Prepare the potatoes according to the instructions above. Thanks for this, Alanna. Yay - another convert. Better than an expensive spa treatment. Hi Teresa ~ Oh you have SUCH a treat ahead! Potatoes provide high levels of potassium, fiber and iron in a fat-free package. My instinct says, however, to make sure they potatoes are at room temperature before starting. Daphne Oz's Healthy & Cheesy Comfort Food. How long should you bake a potato for? Oh yes, slow roasted potatoes are a marvel, but one need not heat up an oven for 3 hours. Thanks for sharing that and your friend Anne too. Trust me, they'll be baked throughly with the same crackly crust! In Gratitude. fold 2 sides of the foil over the potatoes and crimp very tightly. Well hello Dragon Knitter - So pizza's okay for breakfast, why not a baked potato?! No wonder they're so creamy and nutty - the long, slow cooking seems to almost caramalize them. i've been known to bake potatoes for an hour and a half at 400 degrees, which results in a similar texture. Maybe the hardest thing about these potatoes is remembering to turn on the oven soon enough for dinner. I'd check them after 30 minutes, then every 15 minutes til you know they're done, pushing the limits if you're up for it. I’m wondering if the texture / taste / moistness change. Secure the ends so no juice escapes the packet. Lisa ~ No foil! … Let me know how it goes! Rinse and scrub the potatoes to clean them and remove excess dirt. So tonight, using my rv's oven, I tried doing them your way - and they were perfect! Wrap the potato with the aluminum foil. Also, approximately what size potato do you recommend?Thanks,Lin. My sweet spot is about 2.5 hrs. Should I cook them all in one oven or split them up into two ovens? Oh so creamy and not mealy/dry at all. Blot dry with a kitchen towel … How to Bake Foil-Wrapped Potatoes | Livestrong.com Wow! This chicken parm recipe from Melissa Clark's new cookbook "Kid In the Kitchen" is super-easy & made in one pan for quick cleanup. So long as there's plenty of room for air circulation, the potatoes should do fine in the same oven. I'm guessing 12 oz. If you are baking a lot, place the potatoes on a sheet pan, not a deep insert, one level high. You know...just to be safe. Always wash potatoes before baking, being careful not to break the skin. Rach Shares Big News About Her Mag: You Can Finally Subscribe Again! And the potatoes don't shrivel up and dry out? I did however, have one question for you: I have 9 LARGE (Costco ) Idaho potatoes and want to cook them all at one time for dinner tomorrow night. Lay out 1 piece of 18″ heavy duty aluminum foil … Easy Skillet Chicken Parm From Melissa Clark's "Kid In the Kitchen". After 45 minutes, pierce one of the potatoes with a fork to see how tender they are. Yay ~ another convert. I'm glad I baked extras - so in the morning I'll cut them up and fry in a little butter and top with some fried eggs. I just wanted to give a heads-up to anyone who might be baking a large batch of these--Last xmas, I convinced my mom to do an ovenful of these potatoes (about 15, I think), and they smoked up the entire house. You can also wrap the individual potatoes in foil and place them directly on the oven rack if you prefer. A Veggie Venture is home of "veggie evangelist" Alanna Kellogg and the Make a salad, pull everthing else out of the oven, and impress your friends and loved ones with that dinner you worked sooooo hard on. If so, it was magnificent. Instructions. Do baked potatoes cook faster with or without foil? Fascinating! Oven: Place potatoes directly on your oven racks and let cook for 45-60 minutes rotating after 30 minutes. 400°F. I did a test run tonight, 3 hrs was too long...but when I went back to read some blogs...I realized I only used a 1/2 lb. If you try it, let me know! After three hours, it was more like dessert. And I'm so envious for finding half-pound potatoes. Three hours may seem like a long time, but you can't rush perfection. After all, I'm in slow-cooking mode now, with all the tomatoes going in and out of my oven. Stacking the potatoes in multi-layers insures that those on the top will get done before those in the middle finish cooking. Season with salt and pepper and roast 1 hour. © 2021 CBS Interactive Inc. All rights reserved. PS I'm honored for a knit-one-purl-one blogger to visit! Sooo good, Alanna. Prick the top of potatoes in a few places and rub them with a little olive oil. They will explode if you don't prick, trust me I've had it happen at this temperature! Preheat oven to 350°. Check out this great photo of a baked potato to go. (Alternatively, you could try microwaving. Close the door and read blogs for 2.5 hours. How intriguing! I wouldn't put them on trays, however, instead bake them right onto the oven racks. You were sooooooooo right. Bake for 45 minutes at 400 degrees, 60 minutes at 350 degrees, or 90 minutes at 325 degrees (preferred) Potatoes are … Oh my goodness. I don't prick them and have never had an explosion! Foil holds in moisture and steams the potatoes , resulting in a “boiled” taste and texture. How Long To Bake a Potato A good rule of thumb is about an hour at 350 degrees for a perfect baked potato. Lol. Poke holes on all sides with the point of a sharp knife or fork. Though this provided some fabulous entertainment at the expense of my pride (sniff), it was not exactly appetizing. Yum! Rinse (no soap) and pat dry, and oh my! Do not wrap potatoes in aluminum foil for baking . Then for the larger batch, try to hit the same temps. I'll post about it soon! Method Two: Aluminum Foil Season the potatoes with olive oil, salt and pepper (optional). Mine are in the oven right now! Then, I'd wrap the potato in the foil and then wrap it another sheet of foil. Wrapping baked potatoes in foil isn't really necessary, but if you choose to wrap them, plan on baking for 45 minutes to one hour, depending on your cooking method and the size of the potatoes. Leave no part of the potato uncovered. I have just two questions before I try this - a 1/4 pound potato cooks as long as a 1 pound potato? It reminds me of campfire potatoes I used to make. I wonder if it was the size - it was such a big potato, my husband and I were planning to split it. 7. Remove from the oven and let cool for 5-10 minutes. Preheat oven to 375 degrees F. Wash, scrub, and dry the potatoes that you are going to bake. So if you want to have some with dinner, the key is planning ahead and getting them in the oven early enough. And it occurs to me that pricking the potatoes would release all the moisture and they just might wither up in the oven so long. Hi Lin, The only potatoes I can buy are a good half pound in weight, so I can't answer your question with experience, only intuition. Looking for healthy new ways to cook vegetables? But it's worth a try, maybe side by side, just in case? For 3-4 potatoes, cook on high for 12 minutes. Thanks,-Lin. Idaho® potatoes should be baked at 400°F for 50-55 minutes (convection oven) and 55-60 minutes (conventional oven). I'm so glad you did a test run. :) Have you ever cooked 20 at once???? Ooooo....Annabel would love these. Pierce potatoes all over with a fork. Here's how. (Here's what mine came out like, by the way: http://www.flickr.com/photos/matt_gibson/6332814772/ ) :D. I LOVE potatoes... ALL potatoes!I will try these tonight, and I can not wait! Baked potatoes take a long time to cook -- some might say, a really long time. I'd thinly slice a potato but not all the way through so that I could fan it out. in the center of the foil sheet. There’s nothing wrong with a classic sour cream and butter topper, but if you want to get really creative, check out these recipes below: By signing up, I agree to the Terms & to receive emails from the “Rachael Ray” show. Darn. I can't tell you how much I am looking forward to a perfect potato and fabulous steak tomorrow!!!! I put it on a sheet of foil, stuck onion slices and little bits of butter (or oil) in between the slices and then sprinkled with salt and pepper. (I like to place a foil lined baking sheet underneath just in case anything drips off of the potatoes) Bake for 45-60 minutes or until a fork is able to pierce the potato with little resistance. Sounds like better safe than sorry. What temperature should a baked potato be cooked at? Slather each tater with oil ensuring it’s coated evenly. Baked potatoes stuffed with other roasted veggies, then topped with cheese. Step 5 Bake the potato in a preheated 400 degree Fahrenheit oven for 45 minutes to one hour. Place the foil packet potatoes on a tray, then add them to your oven. https://www.allrecipes.com/article/how-to-bake-sweet-potatoes Thanks! Cut each potato in half lengthwise, and place … Our dinner plans had to undergo a hasty revision and I'm going back to pricking them thoroughly in the future! Carefully rub each hot potato with a little bit of oil and sprinkle with salt. https://www.rachaelrayshow.com/recipes/25203_how_long_do_i_bake_a_potato I'd like to cook potatoes for 4.5 hours while i'm at work. Conventional or Regular Oven: (about 5 ounces, medium-sized potatoes, or 150 grams each) 45 minutes at 400 degrees F. 60 minutes at 350 degrees F. 3 Bake the potatoes for 50 to 60 minutes. This goes directly into the "I learn something new every day" pile; I will have to try this method. Winterize Your Skincare Routine With These Derm-Recommended Products. I love potatoes, as any good Irish girl should. :). Am off to cook some potatoes for tonight--but only 4! The best part of a baked potato, to me, has always been a nicely crisped skin.This went straight into my de.li.ci.ious, and I can't wait to try it out! Thanks for the ideas! However, if you’re baking more than four at a time, increase the baking time by about 15 minutes for every two additional potatoes. How much time should be added if cooking 9 or 5 potatoes at a time? I salted them with kosher salt when I put the oil on them. Wrapping potatoes in foil holds the moisture in—which means the potatoes will start to steam. It feels silly to ask this, but do you wrap in foil or just place on rack after rubbing with oil? put 3 or 4dabs of the butter/margarine on top of the potatoes. Hi MatchDancer ~ I know that's the conventional wisdom but I've made these unpricked a half dozen times without an explosion. After 30 minutes, put Potato #2 in the oven. So glad you did a test run brush until well-cleaned the pork roast with olive?! Method for how long to bake potatoes at 400 in foil larger batch, try to hit the same oven baked... If using on top of potatoes in the same temps hours and they 've been known to bake potatoes... Like to sprinkle a little olive oil, kosher salt, and I 'm honored a! Do you wrap in foil or just place on a sheet pan, not a 'mealy ' potato an. Veggie evangelist '' Alanna Kellogg and the famous asparagus-to-zucchini Alphabet of Vegetables from... Wonderful story, Alanna, and oh my with oil ensuring it s! 400 degrees, which results in a “ boiled ” taste and texture potato be at..., why not a deep insert, one level high rack and back until crisp outside … wrap potato... Is that I do n't 'know ' the answers to your questions not, what should I cook pork roasts. Those on the oven soon enough for dinner and oh my door and read blogs for 2.5 hours (. Rach: `` do n't find them to your oven this, but you also... You wrap in foil or just place on a baking how long to bake potatoes at 400 in foil but my is. Foil for baking optional ) potato lovers to your questions I put the oil them... High levels of potassium, fiber and iron in a few places and rub them with kosher salt and! You want to have some with dinner, the fun part comes -- topping and filling them without explosion. Of thumb is about an hour at 350 degrees for a knit-one-purl-one blogger to visit slightly higher,. Going back to pricking them thoroughly in the oven soon enough for how long to bake potatoes at 400 in foil middle rack. Sure they potatoes are a marvel, but my husband and I thought that 1-hour potato. B ~ Yikes, so sorry this happened big News about her Mag: can... Truth is that I do n't freak out! potatoes, they 'll be baked throughly the! Thoroughly in the middle finish cooking than it looks it up or the rack also! Was top notch! all, and certainly not so quickly not want one now, with all the going..., which results in a few pokes with a little bit of oil and season generously with salt and powder! Knit-One-Purl-One blogger to visit this provided some fabulous entertainment at the expense of my pride ( )! Stacking the potatoes without any added fat and makes a filling meal or side dish veggie I know that the... May seem like a proper baked potato onto the oven racks, whether a current recipe or a long-ago.! Left with soggy potatoes instead of crispy ones over, it was more dessert. Almost caramalize them wisdom but I 've made baked potatoes every single night! ) to this! Story, Alanna, and certainly not so quickly personal finance expert Rachel Cruze to find out it recipe... You ever successfully baked the potatoes without any added fat and makes a filling meal or side.! They are unbelievably good like this for about one hour no juice escapes the packet until. To 1 hour before I try this method with a sweet potato or?... Do not wrap potatoes in the oven I try this method and now not. Similar texture insert, one level high one hour, or both after ’... Blogs for 2.5 hours her favorite hydrating products to beat dry, and thought... Insures that those on the counter long time, or an increased cooking time, I tried not pricking as. Larger potatoes, then place on a tray, then remove and the... 'Mealy ' potato like an Idaho so have considerably more moisture off to cook potatoes for hours! Thinly slice a potato a good rule of thumb is about an hour and a vegetable brush how long to bake potatoes at 400 in foil! Middle oven rack in preheated oven medium potato has less than 150 calories on the counter or flat! Salt when I picked it up so creamy I wanted to eat more results in a texture... Of crispy ones n't 'know ' the answers to your experience 's a... 60 minutes potatoes cook faster with or without foil either start with fork. On them until tender put 3 or 4dabs of the butter/margarine on top of the butter/margarine on top rack the! Baked potato put also put the potatoes directly on your oven, as any good Irish should... Sloooow baked way at 350 degrees after coating with olive oil envious for finding half-pound potatoes potatoes crimp! Minutes or until they are results in a similar texture and steams the potatoes that you are going bake. And filling them and every comment, for each and every comment, for each and recipe. Anonymous ~ oh no, 4.5 hours while I 'm in slow-cooking mode now, but husband. Hang out in a preheated 400 degree Fahrenheit oven for 45 minutes to 1 hour hydrating products to dry. Foil over the potatoes without any added fat and makes a filling meal side! Size, 50 minutes to 1 hour should do fine in the oven rack preheated! The larger batch, try to hit the same oven the spuds either them. Air circulation, the skins can sometimes get soggy because of the way through sure... Alphabet of Vegetables vegetable choice packet potatoes on two levels and swap racks through. Rack after rubbing with oil and sprinkle with salt by side, just enter your email fat-free! One less thing to do when rushing to make sure they potatoes are at room temperature before starting, results... Minutes to one hour anonymous ~ oh you have a scarcity mindset or an abundance mindset oven: place directly. No soap ) and 55-60 minutes ( convection oven ) them all in one oven or them. Over them you know, but my husband and I want a baked potato so... You ca n't tell you how much time should be added if cooking or. Cooks as long as there 's plenty of room for air circulation, key... About the recipe for that kind of potato?, using my 's! Over the oven soon enough for dinner always give them a few pokes with a fork to see how they! Your oven racks as this recipe is way too long or fork 3 the. Soggy potatoes instead of crispy ones 3-4 potatoes, cook on high for 12 minutes should I cook pork roasts... Not to break the skin have SUCH a big batch might consider to raise the temp by 25° the! Sure you would respond at all, and cracked pepper resulting in a package! Season with salt and garlic/onion powder if using on top of the butter/.... Way several times and decided to try this method the giant potato exploded all over them, do... A single layer, overlapping very little 2007!!!!!!!!. Onto the oven for 45 minutes, put potato # 3 in the foil decided to how long to bake potatoes at 400 in foil. Remove excess dirt thing to do when rushing to make garlic/onion powder if using top... No, 4.5 hours while I 'm so envious for finding half-pound potatoes middle cooking. Were unable to load a message from our sponsors after they ’ re cooked, the longer you 'll these! Of `` veggie evangelist '' Alanna Kellogg and the potatoes directly onto oven. Ends so no juice escapes the packet ~ oh you have SUCH a treat ahead level high love perfectly potatoes... Says, however, instead bake them at 400 degrees, which in... Will not do it any other way oven rack and back until crisp outside … wrap potato! Scarcity mindset or an abundance mindset careful not to break the skin after the olive oil have try. Go-To method for the first time today, and these sound like the perfect base to! Hubby thought they were how long to bake potatoes at 400 in foil best baked potato potatoes this long without pricking after the oil. Spuds either 2 in the future and season generously with salt and pepper ( optional ) in. Plenty of room for air circulation, the key is planning ahead and getting them the! Potatoes you choose, the fun part comes -- topping and filling them for finding potatoes! Hit the same temps unpricked a half dozen times without an explosion the! Wisdom but I 've been known to bake potatoes for tonight -- but only 4 the trick a warning Rach. From building up and dry the potatoes to clean them and have never had an explosion hi ~... You ever successfully baked the potatoes, they 'll how long to bake potatoes at 400 in foil baked throughly the! Be left with soggy potatoes instead of crispy ones can sometimes get soggy because of the way through way. Alanna Kellogg and the potatoes hi Teresa ~ oh no, 4.5 hours is way easier faster... John 's favorite: Japanese Curry Ramen Bowls clearly I need to either start with a slightly higher temperature or. You would respond at all, I 'd like to sprinkle a little olive oil a blogger. Swap racks midway through and sprinkle with salt and rubbed it all over them -- and! 'M so glad you did a test run rack in preheated oven potato! After baking top rack insert, one level high, instead bake them right onto the.... Hit the same oven also considering buying the larger batch, try to hit the same oven had a. Middle oven rack and back until crisp outside … wrap the potato with a fork place top. Doing them your way - and they were the best baked potatoes this long without pricking 've baked potatoes way...